Se Habla Español
Мы говорим по-русски
Category

Personal Injury

Multi-car crash at an intersection where California Proposition 51 may split fault

California Proposition 51

By | Personal Injury

California Proposition 51: How Fault Is Split Between Defendants

California Proposition 51 splits non-economic damages, such as pain and suffering, by fault. When several defendants share the blame, each answers only for its own percentage of those damages. Economic damages, such as medical bills and lost earnings, stay joint. So any responsible defendant can be liable for all of them.

This guide explains where the rule comes from and how the two kinds of damages differ. It also covers what happens when a defendant cannot pay or is not in the lawsuit.

What is California Proposition 51?

California Proposition 51 is the Fair Responsibility Act of 1986, a voter initiative approved in June 1986. Today it sits in Civil Code sections 1431 to 1431.5. It changed the old rule, which let an injured person collect all damages from any one defendant. That was true however small the defendant’s share of fault.

The findings in section 1431.1 describe that old approach as a “deep pocket” rule. Under it, a defendant with money or insurance but little fault could end up covering the whole loss. So the stated goal was to tie each defendant’s liability more closely to its own degree of fault.

The core rule sits in Civil Code section 1431.2. In an injury, property damage or wrongful death case based on comparative fault, liability for non-economic damages is several only, not joint. In plain terms, each defendant owes its own slice. The court enters a separate judgment against each one for that amount.

What is the difference between economic and non-economic damages under Proposition 51?

Medical bills and a pay stub, two kinds of economic damages

Economic damages are money losses you can verify, such as medical expenses, lost earnings, repair costs and burial costs. Non-economic damages are losses without a price tag, such as pain, suffering, emotional distress and loss of companionship. Section 1431.2(b) defines both, and Proposition 51 limits only the second kind.

That line matters because the two kinds follow different rules. For economic damages, each responsible defendant can still be liable for the full amount, after any reduction for your own share. For non-economic damages, each defendant answers only for its percentage. In a 1992 decision, the California Supreme Court confirmed that Proposition 51 kept joint liability for economic losses.

How does Proposition 51 work in a crash with several defendants?

City intersection with several cars, where more than one driver may share fault

It works in two steps. First, the jury sets each person’s percentage of fault and finds your total damages. Then each defendant owes non-economic damages only in line with its own percentage. Meanwhile, any responsible defendant can still be liable for the full economic damages, which keeps that part of the claim joint.

Here is an illustration, not a real case. Say your car sits at a red light when two other cars collide in the intersection and one spins into yours. A jury finds the first driver 70 percent at fault for running the light. It finds the second driver 30 percent at fault for speeding. You were not at fault.

For non-economic damages, the first driver is responsible for 70 percent and the second driver for 30 percent. For economic damages, either driver can be liable for the full amount.

What happens when one defendant cannot pay?

It depends on the type of damages. For economic damages, you may still collect the full amount from a defendant who can pay. For non-economic damages, the missing share of a defendant with no insurance or assets does not shift to the other defendants. The California Supreme Court has said the injured person now carries that risk.

In the illustration, say the first driver has no insurance and no assets. The second driver can still be liable for all of your economic damages, but for only 30 percent of the non-economic damages. That is one reason your own uninsured motorist coverage may matter after a multi-car crash.

Can fault be assigned to someone who is not in the lawsuit?

Yes. A jury compares the fault of everyone responsible for the harm, not only the defendants at trial. In the same 1992 decision, the California Supreme Court held that this includes an injured worker’s employer. That holds even though workers’ compensation rules generally keep the worker from suing it. Each defendant’s share is a percentage of all the fault involved.

CACI 406, the standard jury instruction on apportionment, lets the defense point to people who are not at trial, such as someone who settled earlier. Any share the jury gives an absent person is a share the defendants at trial do not owe for non-economic damages.

So it helps to know early who else may share the blame, from another driver to a property owner. A personal injury lawyer in Los Angeles can look at every possible defendant before the deadlines pass.

How does Proposition 51 interact with your own share of fault?

Your own share comes first. Under California’s pure comparative fault rule, your total damages go down by your own percentage. Then Proposition 51 divides the non-economic damages among the defendants by their percentages, and you carry your own part. Economic damages, after that reduction, remain joint.

Now change the illustration. Say you were 10 percent at fault, the first driver 60 percent and the second driver 30 percent. Your economic damages would drop by 10 percent, and either driver could be liable for the rest. For non-economic damages, the first driver would answer for 60 percent and the second for 30 percent, leaving 10 percent with you.

Viciti Law’s post on contributory fault explains how a jury sets your own share.

Frequently asked questions

Does Proposition 51 apply to medical bills?

No, not in the way it applies to pain and suffering. Section 1431.2 lists medical expenses as economic damages, and Proposition 51 limits only non-economic damages. So any defendant found responsible can still be liable for your full medical expenses, reduced by your own share of fault, if any.

Is Proposition 51 the same as Proposition 213?

No. Proposition 51, from 1986, divides non-economic damages among defendants by fault. Proposition 213, from 1996, is Civil Code section 3333.4. In a vehicle case, it bars non-economic damages for three groups, with one exception: a driver convicted of DUI for the crash, an uninsured owner and a driver who cannot show financial responsibility.

Does Proposition 51 apply to an employer’s liability for its driver?

Not to split an employer from its own employee. Sometimes an employer is liable only because its employee was driving on the job. In that case, California’s Supreme Court has held that the employer’s liability matches the employee’s share of fault. The two count as one share, and Proposition 51 divides fault among the independent wrongdoers.

How long do I have to file?

For most injury claims, the deadline is two years from the injury under Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1. Property damage claims generally have three years under section 338. If a public entity is one of the defendants, a written claim is due within six months under Government Code section 911.2. Proposition 51 does not change these deadlines.

Talk to Viciti Law About Proposition 51

If more than one person or business may share the blame for your injury, the split can affect what each one owes. To sort out who is responsible, contact Viciti Law for a free consultation or call (310) 919-5011.

The office is at 13743 Ventura Blvd, Suite 240, in Sherman Oaks. The firm speaks Spanish and Russian, and it takes each and every case personally.

Book Free Consultation (button, links to /contact-us/)

Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome. This article provides general information about California law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney Advertising.

Cracked step where a fall raised a question of contributory fault

Contributory Fault

By | Personal Injury

Contributory Fault in California: Can You Recover If You Were Partly to Blame?

Yes. California dropped the old contributory fault rule in 1975, so being partly to blame does not bar your claim. Instead, your own share of fault reduces your damages, even if your share is larger than the other side’s.

If an adjuster has said you were partly at fault for a crash or a fall, this guide explains what that means. It also covers who decides the percentages, which claims the rule reaches and what can lower your share.

What is contributory fault?

Contributory fault, usually called contributory negligence, was an all-or-nothing rule. It barred any recovery if the injured person shared any of the blame. Under it, a driver who was 1 percent at fault could recover nothing. The California Supreme Court replaced that rule in Li v. Yellow Cab Co. in 1975, and it no longer applies here.

In Li, the court adopted a pure form of comparative negligence. Your own negligence no longer bars recovery. Instead, your damages shrink in proportion to your share. The basic duty still comes from Civil Code section 1714, which makes everyone responsible for harm their lack of ordinary care causes.

You may still hear the old term from an adjuster. After a crash, many people also ask, is California a no-fault state? It is not, and fault decides who is responsible.

How does comparative fault work in California?

Notepad showing fault split into two percentages

Comparative fault gives each person a percentage of the blame, and your damages go down by your own percentage. If you were 25 percent at fault, you can still recover 75 percent of your damages. Your share lowers the amount, but it does not close the door, even when it is the larger share.

For example, say you trip on a broken step at a store while carrying a box that blocks your view. Suppose a jury finds the owner 70 percent at fault for the step. It finds you 30 percent at fault for not seeing the step. The judge then reduces your damages by 30 percent.

That percentage applies to your total damages, not to a single bill. So it reaches medical expenses, lost earnings and pain and suffering alike.

The same math applies after a T-bone car accident where one driver ran a red light and the other was speeding.

Who decides the percentages?

If a case goes to trial, the jury decides. Under CACI 405, the standard California jury instruction, the defense must prove that you were negligent and that your negligence was a substantial factor in causing your harm. The jury then sets your percentage, and the judge calculates the reduction.

Before trial, an adjuster may propose a split. That number is the insurer’s position, not a finding, and it may change as evidence comes in. Each side can point to the same evidence a jury would weigh, so the facts matter long before any trial. When several people share the blame, a related instruction, CACI 406, asks the jury to assign percentages that total 100 percent.

Does comparative fault apply to every kind of injury claim?

It applies to negligence claims, such as car crashes and falls on someone else’s property. In a 1978 decision, the California Supreme Court extended comparative fault to strict product liability claims. So a person hurt by a defective product can have their recovery reduced by their own fault, but not barred.

Premises claims rest on the same section 1714, which covers how people manage their property. Passengers and pedestrians fall under the same rule, too. A passenger who did nothing to cause a crash may carry no share at all. A pedestrian’s share, if any, depends on the facts, such as where and how they crossed. In each case, the defense has to prove the injured person’s carelessness.

How is fault split when several people share it?

When more than one person shares the blame, the jury gives each a percentage, and the percentages total 100 percent. Your own share comes off first. Then Civil Code section 1431.2, adopted by Proposition 51, limits each defendant’s liability for non-economic damages, such as pain and suffering, to its own share. Economic damages follow a different rule.

What can lower your share of fault?

Person photographing a hazard on a floor with a phone

Evidence. Because the defense has to prove your share, facts showing you acted with reasonable care can keep it small or remove it. Photos, video, witness accounts, the police report and records made at the time can carry more weight than anyone’s memory months later.

  • Photos of the scene, the vehicles, the lighting and any hazard, taken as soon as you can.
  • Video from dashcams, doorbells or nearby businesses, which may not stay on file for long.
  • Names and phone numbers of witnesses.
  • The police or CHP report, and any incident report the property owner made.
  • Medical records that show when you sought care and what you reported.

For a fall, the condition of the floor and how long a hazard sat there may matter as much as where you were looking. For a crash, the other driver’s speed, signals and phone use count too. It also helps to write down what you remember soon after, while the details are fresh. A personal injury lawyer in Los Angeles can help gather that evidence before it disappears.

Frequently asked questions

Can I recover if I was more than half at fault?

Yes. California follows pure comparative fault, so there is no 50 percent cutoff. If you were 60 percent at fault, you can still recover 40 percent of your damages. Li v. Yellow Cab Co. adopted the pure form, which applies even when your share is larger than the other side’s.

Does not wearing a seat belt count against me?

It can. Under Vehicle Code section 27315, skipping a seat belt does not count as negligence in itself in a civil case. Still, the defense may try to prove it as a fact. Under CACI 712, it must show a working belt was available, a careful person would have worn it, and wearing it would have prevented or reduced your injuries.

Will my statement to the adjuster affect fault?

It can. Under Evidence Code section 1220, the other side can offer your own statements against you if the case goes to court. A quick “I didn’t see them” in a recorded call can become part of the fault argument. So before you give a recorded statement to the other side’s insurer, consider speaking with a lawyer.

How long do I have to file?

For most personal injury claims, the deadline is two years from the injury under Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1. Property damage claims generally have three years under section 338. If a public entity is involved, a written claim is due within six months under Government Code section 911.2. Your share of fault does not change these deadlines.

Talk to Viciti Law About Contributory Fault

If an adjuster has put part of the blame on you, that number is not the last word. Viciti Law can review the report, the photos and the adjuster’s numbers with you. To talk through the facts, contact Viciti Law for a free consultation or call (310) 919-5011.

The office is at 13743 Ventura Blvd, Suite 240, in Sherman Oaks. The firm speaks Spanish and Russian, and it takes each and every case personally.

Book Free Consultation (button, links to /contact-us/)

Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome. This article provides general information about California law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney Advertising.

City bus at a Los Angeles stop, a common source of claims under the California Tort Claims Act

California Tort Claims Act

By | Personal Injury

The California Tort Claims Act: Claims Against Cities, Counties and Schools

The California Tort Claims Act sets the rules for injury claims against cities, counties, school districts and other public entities. Before you sue one of them for money, you generally must present a written claim to it. For most injury claims, that claim is due within six months.

Below are the parts that matter most after an injury, from who the Act covers to what to do if time has passed.

What is the California Tort Claims Act?

It is the informal name for Government Code section 810 and the sections that follow it. Together they decide when a public entity can be responsible and how you bring a claim. The core rule is simple: the written claim comes first, and the lawsuit can only come after.

Under Government Code section 945.4, you generally cannot sue a public entity for money until you present a written claim. You also wait until the entity acts on it, or until the law treats the claim as rejected.

You may also see a different name. In City of Stockton v. Superior Court (2007), the California Supreme Court adopted the name Government Claims Act. The claim rules reach well beyond tort cases, and Section 810 now uses that name as well.

Who counts as a public entity?

Exterior of a city government building where a claim against a public entity is presented

Government Code section 811.2 gives a broad answer. A public entity includes the state, the University of California and the California State University. It also includes every county and city, and any district, public authority, public agency or other political subdivision in California. So the California Tort Claims Act reaches school districts and transit agencies.

Near Sherman Oaks, that can mean the City of Los Angeles, Los Angeles County or a public school district. It can also mean a public housing authority. Viciti Law’s article on negligent security claims covers when an owner may be responsible for crime on its property, such as an apartment complex. When the owner is public, the claim step comes first.

What deadlines apply under the California Tort Claims Act?

The main deadline is six months. Government Code section 911.2 sets it for claims of death, personal injury or damage to personal property. The six months run from the date the claim accrues. Most other claims have one year. After that, the entity and the courts each run on their own clocks.

The chain usually looks like this:

  • You have six months to present an injury or death claim, under Section 911.2.
  • The entity’s board then has 45 days to act on it, under Section 912.4. If the board does nothing, the law treats the claim as rejected on the last day.
  • After a written notice of rejection, you have six months to file suit, under Section 945.6.
  • If no written notice comes, the same section allows two years from accrual.

So a claim against a public entity runs on a faster clock than the two-year deadline for most injury suits. A personal injury lawyer in Los Angeles can help you map these dates against your own facts early.

What does the claim have to include?

Government Code section 910 lists what the claim must show. You give your name and mailing address, where notices should go, and the date, place and circumstances of what happened. Then you describe the injury or loss, name any public employees involved if you know them, and address the amount.

The amount rule surprises people. If the claim totals less than $10,000, you state the amount and how you figured it. If it is more than $10,000, Section 910 says you leave the dollar figure out. Instead, you state whether the case would be a limited civil case.

Keep a copy of everything you send, along with proof of the date you sent it. Photos, medical records and witness names can matter later, too.

When is a public entity responsible for an injury?

Cracked public sidewalk that may be a dangerous condition of public property

A public entity is responsible only when a statute says it is. Government Code section 815 states that, except as a statute provides, a public entity is not liable for an injury. In injury cases, the rules that can apply cover employees, dangerous public property and public vehicles.

Each one works a little differently:

  • Employees: under Section 815.2, a public entity can be liable for an employee’s act on the job. That applies when the act would also support a claim against the employee.
  • Vehicles: under Vehicle Code section 17001, a public entity is liable when an employee’s negligent driving on the job causes injury.
  • Property: under Government Code section 835, a public entity can be liable for a dangerous condition of its property. The condition must have caused the injury and created a foreseeable risk. An employee also must have created it, or the entity must have had notice in time to protect against it.

The Act also contains immunities, and Section 815 makes liability subject to them. Some can block a claim entirely. For example, under Section 818, a public entity is not liable for punitive damages. Section 830 also sets a threshold: a condition that creates only a minor or trivial risk does not count as dangerous.

After a fall on a broken sidewalk, a pedestrian accident lawyer in Los Angeles can check it against Section 835.

What if you missed the six-month deadline?

You may still have options. Government Code section 911.4 lets you apply in writing to the public entity for leave to present a late claim. The application has to arrive within a reasonable time, and no later than one year after the claim accrued. It must explain the delay and attach the proposed claim.

If the entity says no, Section 946.6 lets you petition the superior court within six months of the denial. The court looks at grounds such as excusable neglect, a minor’s age, incapacity or death. Because that one-year limit has very few exceptions, act as soon as a public entity seems to have a part.

Frequently asked questions

Does the Act apply to a crash with a city bus?

Yes. A city is a public entity under Government Code section 811.2. So a written claim generally has to come before any lawsuit. Vehicle Code section 17001 also makes a public entity liable when an employee’s negligent driving on the job causes injury. For an injury, the claim is generally due within six months.

Can I bring a claim against a school district?

Yes. Section 811.2 lists districts among public entities, and a public school district is one of them. You present the claim to the district itself. Generally, you deliver it to its clerk or secretary, or mail it to its governing body. A claim about an unsafe campus may rest on the dangerous condition rule in Section 835.

Is the deadline different for a minor?

The six months in Section 911.2 does not pause for a child. Instead, the late claim rules help. Under Section 911.6, the board must grant a timely late claim application for someone who was a minor during the six months. Even then, Section 911.4 still requires the application within one year after the claim accrued.

Where do I file the claim?

You file it with the public entity, not the court. Under Government Code section 915, a claim against a city, county or district goes to its clerk, secretary or auditor. You can also mail it to its governing body. Online filing works only where the entity allows it. Most claims against the state go to the Department of General Services.

Talk to Viciti Law About a Claim Against a Public Entity

If a city vehicle, a county road or a school played a part in your injury, the six-month clock may already be running. To talk it through, contact Viciti Law for a free consultation or call (310) 919-5011.

The office is at 13743 Ventura Blvd, Suite 240, in Sherman Oaks. The firm speaks Spanish and Russian, and it takes each and every case personally.

Book Free Consultation (button, links to /contact-us/)

Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome. This article provides general information about California law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney Advertising.